Mark Twain on reading novels:
I have no liking for novels or stories -- none in the world; and so, whenever I read one -- which is not oftener than once in two years, and even in these same cases I seldom read beyond the middle of the book -- my distaste for the vehicle always taints my judgment of the literature itself...and also of course makes my verdict valueless. Are you saying "You have written stories yourself?" Quite true: but the fact that an Indian likes to scalp people is no evidence that he likes to be scalped.
- letter to Bruce Weston Munro, 15 March 1887
- letter to Bruce Weston Munro, 15 March 1887
I tried, people. I really did. I wanted to be in the ol' S&M Fifty Shades lady club who ohh'ed and ahh'ed and giggled and simpered over this stupid, stupid, stupid series. For God's sake, I read the Twilight series in week! Popular and poorly written is usually not much of a barrier for me. But here it is: I HATE FIFTY SHADES! It occurred to me after skimming through 157 pages of the tedious 3rd novel that I had only read perhaps three pages but had rolled my eyes, gagged, and convulsed like 9,271 times. So I am doing something I don't ever remember doing: I am tossing this drivel on the burn heap. I will not read another word. Done. Finit!
Ok-so what's my complaint, you ask? Weak character & plot development is a biggie; vapid and sophomoric dialogue that is so 8th grade-like, for realzzz; a gluttony of material possessions that not even billionaires aspire to; unrealistic and chauvinistic sex-capades that no man or woman could perform even with the aid of a genie in bottle; and a docile, spineless heroine who whispers and casts her eyes down and questions nothing ever! I want to kick her in the head. Seriously???
I understand the allure of fantasy and using fiction as a means of experience or escape. And I confess, I am a literature snob on many levels. But at some point, characters need pores, texture, and frankly...to struggle and muddle through the muck and grime of life-or else why bother to spend $12.95 and three or more hours of your life with them? So I am returning to some tried and true writers who deliver some entertainment bang for the buck: Diana Gabaldon, Phillipa Gregory, Pat Conroy, Anne Rice, Stephen King, Ken Follett, and good ol' Twain himself, to name a few. So I will be hitting the library or book store soon and looking forward to sinking my teeth into something juicy-or at least to avoid the scalping that Twain so eloquently references.
Happy reading-whatever it may be!

I read it when it was free as Twilight fanfic on the net and it was horrible then-- I'm definitely not paying for the search-and-replace-names version, or the follow ups.
ReplyDeleteIt is truly horrible, and I read fanfic, so you know my tolerance for bad writing is pretty high.
So glad I'm not the only one!!!!! Not to mention the sex is always repetitive, Ana really needs to get a grip, and he's just plain ole creepy. There was also zero plot. Barf!
ReplyDelete-Micah H